In this lesson, students will learn about current trends in student borrowing and determine a reasonable debt load for hypothetical students. College costs have escalated over the past two decades, and more and more students are relying on student loans to cover the costs. Therefore, it is more important than ever to carefully consider the costs of college, your anticipated career income, and how to best finance those college expenses.
According to the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, student loan debt has tripled between 2004 and 2014, and the average amount of debt per borrower in 2014 was $27,000. Most students do not understand the long-term implications of taking on large amounts of student debt and have no idea what their monthly loan payments will be after graduation. Despite the high costs, for most students, it still pays to attend college. However, students need to carefully consider the options for financing their education before utilizing student loans. In this lesson, students will analyze the student loan decisions of hypothetical students, consider ways to reduce the amount to borrow, and examine data to determine wise choices for their own anticipated student loan debt.
We would like to acknowledge the Outreach and Education staff of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York for their contributions to this lesson.
- Analyze trends in student borrowing.
- Identify the costs and benefits of taking out student loans.
- Identify ways to lower the cost of attending college.
- Use online calculators to determine the amount borrowed and monthly payments, and to compare the impacts of changing the amount borrowed.
- Graph of Delinquent Loans (Federal Reserve Bank of New York)
- The Student Loan Landscape. Summary of research by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York
- Earnings information for various occupations: https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes_nat.htm or http://www.careeronestop.org/toolkit/toolkit.aspx
- Federal Student Loan Repayment Estimator: https://studentloans.gov/myDirectLoan/repaymentEstimator.action Estimates monthly payments and full costs of student loans
- College Navigator from the National Center for Education Statistics: https://nces.ed.gov/collegenavigator/ Displays the official published costs of attending colleges
- Is College Worth It?: https://www.frbsf.org/education/teacher-resources/value-of-college/ Interactive with the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco
- College 101: https://www.stlouisfed.org/education_resources/college101/index.html Infographic by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis
- Net Price Calculator from the College Board: https://professionals.collegeboard.org/higher-ed/financial-aid/netprice/participating-schools?excmpid=mtg382-st-1-mat Calculates the estimated net price of attending college, based on parents’ financial records, test scores, and GPA
1. Put the students in small groups of three to five. Students will take the Student Debt Quiz, discussing each question before answering as a group. Encourage students to discuss examples of friends and family members to help guide their answers. After students have had 5-10 minutes to work on the quiz, go over the answers.
Student Debt Quiz
The average amount of debt per undergraduate student borrower in 2014 was:
a. $ 8,000
True or false: Student loan debt can be discharged in bankruptcy .
True or false: You don’t have to repay your student loans if you don’t graduate.
True or false: You don’t start paying interest on your loans until after you graduate.
What is the percentage of 25-year-olds who hold student debt?
True or false: Students who owe less than $5,000 in student debt have higher default rates.
2. In the Hidden Costs of College lesson, students calculated the cost of attendance for two different schools and realized that they may need to take out student loans to cover part or all of their college expenses. In recent years, student loan debt has significantly increased, so it is very important for students to consider not only the cost of college, but the income they can expect to earn in their career after college. If students intend to enter a career which pays a lower income than others, they will need to determine whether borrowing large sums of money to attend their dream college is appropriate.
Show the students the graph below on consumer debt and ask them the following questions:
- What do banks mean when a loan is 90+ days delinquent ? [The loan payment is more than 90 days late.]
- Which type of loan had the highest rate of delinquency in the first quarter of 2004? [Credit card]
- Which type of loan had the highest rate of delinquency in the first quarter of 2015? [Student loan]
3. Ask students to read the article The Student Loan Landscape, which summarizes research on student loan debt by staff members of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Then discuss their answers to the following questions:
- What happened to the amount of student loan debt between 2004 and 2014? [Tripled]
- How much is the average student debt per borrower? [$27,000]
- Why has the amount of college debt increased? [More students attending; students staying longer; less expensive to take out loans; increased cost of college]
- Why is the student loan repayment rate low? [Deferring payments; income-based repayment plans; can’t afford it; cannot be discharged in bankruptcy]
- Is the student loan default rate increasing or decreasing? [Increasing]
- Why are some borrowers, who are making their payments, seeing their loan balance continue to increase? [Their payments are not keeping up with the accruing interest]
- How does significant student loan debt affect a person’s credit score? [Reduces it]
- Why is a credit score important? [It affects the ability to get a home mortgage, an auto loan, or use credit cards.]
- How can the high amount of student debt affect the macro economy? [Students and their parents who are repaying the loans cannot use that money for consumer purchases, which can hurt the macro economy]
- Why is a college degree still a worthwhile investment? [College graduates earn 80% higher income than non-graduates, and graduates are less likely to become unemployed]
4. Tell students that a good rule of thumb is to avoid taking on more debt than they expect to earn in their first year of work. Also, discuss the opportunity cost of these loan payments–what students may have to "give up" in order to make loan payments. Students with significant debt may find that they don't have enough money for a new car or a down payment on a house.
Armed with their background knowledge about student debt, students will read case studies of hypothetical students and advise them regarding a manageable amount of money to borrow.
For the first two case studies, have students use one of the following websites to find the salaries the students in the case studies can expect to earn: https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes_nat.htm or http://www.careeronestop.org/toolkit/toolkit.aspx . Have students divide annual income by 12 to determine monthly gross income.
For all four case studies, have students use the interest repayment estimator to determine the monthly student loan payment: https://studentloans.gov/myDirectLoan/repaymentEstimator.action
Click "Add Loan," select "Direct Unsubsidized Loan," and type in the amount to be borrowed. Use 4.29% as the interest rate. This is the interest rate for https://www.investopedia.com/personal-finance/federal-direct-loans-subsidized-vs-unsubsidized/ federal student loans initiated in 2015-2016. Use the Standard Rate as the monthly repayment cost.
Have students compare the monthly income to the monthly student loan repayment. How would the students advise each student in the case studies?
- Jason wants to become an elementary school teacher. His dream school is out of state, which will require him to borrow $191,560. [His monthly loan payment would consume more than 40% of his monthly income. He should look for less expensive schools.]
- Alex wants to become a welder. She can complete a one-year program at her local community college, which requires her to borrow $14,523. [Her monthly loan payment would consume less than 5% of her monthly income. It is a reasonable loan debt.]
- Shawn spent his first year of college partying and skipping classes. As a result of his poor grades, he will now have to attend a fifth year of college in order to obtain his four-year degree. He will have to borrow an additional $23,032 for his fifth year. Assuming a $40,000 income after graduation, by how much will his monthly loan payment increase for the next ten years? By how much will his total loan increase, including interest? [$236] [$28,378]
- Sam took several AP and dual credit courses in high school, which will allow her to graduate one semester early. Assuming a $40,000 income, if one semester’s cost of attendance is $12,530, what is the total amount she will save in loan debt? [$15,439]
5. Discuss with students ways they can reduce college costs, reducing their reliance on student loans.
- Complete your FAFSA form and apply for as many scholarships as possible — even the little ones
- Take AP or dual credit classes while in high school
- Carefully compare your options for housing and meal plans; consider what you can afford
- Graduate on time; work with your adviser early to select courses and keep up your grades
- Buy or rent used textbooks
- Buy only what you need; you don’t need every college sweatshirt, towel, and hat
- Check to see whether local businesses offer discounts with a student ID
- Pay bills on time to avoid paying interest charges and late fees
- Work at least part-time while in school to reduce the amount you need to borrow
At a time when college costs are higher than ever, it is important to carefully consider the level of student debt a student should carry. It is critical for students to plan in advance, find ways to reduce their college costs, and be realistic in selecting a college with costs the student will be able to afford to repay.
Given concerns about the size of student loan debt, is a college education worth it? Absolutely. Even though costs have escalated in the past decade, a college degree is still a worthwhile investment for most students. On average, college graduates earn significantly more income than non-graduates, and they are less likely to become unemployed. A study by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York found that the return on investment in a college education (calculating the costs and benefits of a bachelor’s degree) is approximately 15% – more than double the 7% historical rate of return in the stock market! Of course, not all degrees are equal. Engineers saw a 21% return on investment, while teachers only saw a 9% return on investment. But given the trends of falling wages for those with high school diplomas, compared to stagnant wages for those with a college degree, the benefits of a college degree still outweigh the costs of that degree. To calculate the age at which a college degree will begin to pay off, visit: https://www.frbsf.org/education/teacher-resources/value-of-college/ . To see an infographic about college benefits and costs, visit: https://www.stlouisfed.org/education_resources/college101/index.html . The videos on this website can be useful in supporting the infographic.
Your choice of college and career are among the most important decisions you will ever make. Take the time to do careful research and prepare to reduce your costs, so you can enter a career with minimal debt and make those investments and choices of your dreams!
Students can work with their parents to calculate the estimated net price of attending college. The College Board Net Price Calculator at https://professionals.collegeboard.org/higher-ed/financial-aid/netprice/participating-schools?excmpid=mtg382-st-1-mat bases the estimates on parents’ financial records, test scores, and GPA. Please note that not all schools participate in the Net Price Calculator. In the Net Price Calculator, click on "Participating Schools" and then select a school and "Enter as a Guest" to get started.
Let’s bring this close to home. Have students use the salary indicator to determine their likely salary in the career they are considering: https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes_nat.htm or http://www.careeronestop.org/toolkit/toolkit.aspx .
Next find the estimated annual cost of attendance for the college the student would like to attend. Visit the college’s website or go to https://nces.ed.gov/collegenavigator/ to look up tuition and fees. Students should multiply that annual cost by the number of years they expect to be in college. Although the costs of graduate school tend to be significantly higher than for a four-year degree, for purposes of this lesson, students should just use the same tuition for additional years of graduate school.
Tell the students to assume they must borrow the entire amount to pay for their education. Use the interest repayment calculator to determine the monthly student loan repayment: https://studentloans.gov/myDirectLoan/repaymentEstimator.action
Given what the students have learned in this lesson, ask them to write a paragraph answering each of these questions:
- Given the monthly student loan repayment and projected salary, is this college a smart financial choice? Explain why or why not.
- Explain three specific actions the student could take to reduce the amount of student loans required to finish the college education.