This lesson utilizes the March 18, 2015, statement of the Federal Reserve's Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) to explore the Federal Reserve's twin goals of price stability and full employment. This lesson discusses the difference in language between the most recent release and the one before, and examines the Fed's "dot plots" for clues about the timing of future rate hikes.
The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) of the Federal Reserve System (Fed) meets approximately every six weeks to decide on its use of the two policy tools at its disposal: setting the federal funds rate and engaging in open market operations. (Note: changing the reserve requirement is a rarely used third tool). The federal funds rate is the interest rate at which banks lend funds to other banks, using the Federal Reserve as an intermediary. Open market operations consist of buying and selling financial assets, changing the lending capacity of financial institutions.
The Fed instituted an asset buy-back program in 2008 in an effort to stimulate the economy (QE1). This program has been renewed (QE2 and QE3) until October of 2014. In addition, the FOMC has maintained the federal funds rate target at a range of 0 to 1/4 percent since its December 16, 2008 meeting. The fed funds rate has been kept at this historically low level because of the low (or sometimes negative) growth rates of real GDP due to the lingering effects of the recession.
This lesson uses the March 18, 2015, statement of the FOMC to closely examine how the language in this current release is different than that of the release in January. Students will search for clues, both in the language of the release and in the Fed's "dot plot", for the timing of the rate hike, and what the Fed is looking for before their willingness to vote for a hike.
- Understand the background and meaning of the March 18, 2015, Federal Open Market Committee decision with respect to the federal funds rate
- Examine the language of this report and the January report for difference in language
- Analyze how the language differences reflect the Fed's changing assessment of the economy
- Explore the Fed's "dot plots" to better understand the Fed's predictions about the economy and the timing of a rate hike
- FOMC Monetary Policy press release, March 18, 2015.
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System: This webpage introduces each member of the board.
Federal Reserve Resources for Educators: Here you can find links to instructional materials and tools that can increase your understanding of the Federal Reserve, economics and financial education.
Open Market Operations: This page provides the Federal Reserve's definition and examples of Open Market Operations.
National Economic Indicators: This Federal Reserve Bank webpage explains some of the economic indicators that are used to formulate the nation's monetary policy.
Federal Reserve Consumer Information and Publications web links: This Federal Reserve site provides information, publications, and web links for consumers.
New York Fed: Open Market Operations: This page provides detailed information on open market operations.
About the FOMC: This Federal Reserve page provides detailed information on the FOMC.
Direct students to the statement released by the FOMC on Jan 28, 2015 and have them read the first paragraph. Ask what their impression is– the Fed optimistic or pessimistic about the current economy? (answers will vary, but they state that the labor market continues to grow, household spending and business investment are increasing moderately–in general, good news. They note that export growth has weakened and inflation has continued to fall, two pieces of bad news).
Direct students to the second paragraph. What does the Fed expect to happen in the near term in the labor market and with inflation? (they expect the labor market to continue to improve, getting close to full employment; they expect inflation to remain low). What do they expect in the medium term? (they expect inflation to rise as energy prices begin to increase).
- Direct students to the third paragraph. What did the Fed decide with respect to the federal funds rate? (to keep it within the current range). Tell students that while the Fed is not changing its policy stance, the rest of that paragraph is quite different than previous statements. Point out the box below, which compares the January statement (in red and struck through) with the March statement (in green).
Ask students what the major difference between the two statements is that shows up in the first sentence (they removed the word "patience", and stated that they would not be raising the rate at the April meeting). Many Fed watchers took the language in this portion of the statement to indicate that the Fed would also be unlikely to raise the rate at its June meeting as well. Ask students what about this statement would lead people to that conclusion (the Fed states that further improvement in the labor market is needed and they need evidence that inflation is really going to increase over the medium term, language that does not indicate they are in any hurry to raise the rates).
- Tell students that while Fed watchers pore over the statements that the Fed releases, looking for signs of their intentions and the timing of future rate hikes, there is information that the Fed itself releases that give a more accurate picture of what they are thinking for the future. The Fed's 17-member policy board routinely votes on what they think the federal funds rate will be in the future, one to three years out and then longer term. The Fed releases these data in the form of a "dot plot" (it's got its own Twitter account–#dotplot). Each dot represents one member's vote as to what he/she thinks the federal funds rate should be during the time periods on the horizontal axis. In other words, the dot plot shows the expectations of Fed policy makers about the direction of interest rates.
Tell students that the members of the Fed group are making predictions about their own behavior, so they are really making predictions about 3 things:
- what economic conditions will be
- what they, individually, will want to happen with rates in response to those conditions, and
- what they think they, collectively, will vote to do with rates in response to those conditions
The dot plot for December of 2014 looked like this:
Ask students what they notice about 2015 and the predictions that the Fed members were making (back in Dec. of 2014) about rates (4 members thought that rates would be at 2% at the end of 2015; 2 members thought that interest rates would not rise at all by the end of 2015; the predictions are quite spread out; and the median (middle–9th) prediction is about 1% at the end of this year).
Ask students to look at 2016. Ask what the median prediction is for rates at the end of this year (2.5%). Ask what the high estimate is (4%). Ask what they notice about the spread of 2016's predictions compared to 2015's (it's more spread out than 2015). Ask them if they think that's unusual or to be expected (they should recognize that the further out in time people are making predictions, the more likely it is that the predictions will have a wider distribution. Although interestingly, the long term predictions are fairly narrowly distributed).
Tell students that, in general, members of the Fed group who predict that interest rate will stay low are called "doves" and those that indicate that interest rates will go up are called "hawks".
- Now show students the most recent dot plot, released after the March 2015 meeting:
Ask what they notice about 2015's predictions (the median prediction is lower than it was in December 2014–about 0.6% compared to December's prediction of about 1%; 2 people still think the rate will stay the same; the high estimate is about 1.6%, offered by only one person; the distribution is tighter–not as much difference between members' predictions).
Ask students how the median rate for the end of 2016 compares to the previous prediction for that year, made in December of 2014 (the March prediction for 2016 is about 1.8%, compared to the previous prediction for 2016 of 2.5%).
Looking at the dot plot, what conclusions can students draw about the speed at which the Fed is likely to increase rates? (the Fed is likely to take its time increasing rates). Ask students if the Fed's position is a dovish or hawkish stance (dovish, for the time being).
The Federal Reserve Open Market Committee (FOMC) meets approximately every six weeks to review the Federal Reserve's monetary policy positions. In this latest report, the FOMC notes that the labor market continues to improve. In addition, the FOMC believes that inflation is contained for the short term, but the factors keeping it in check are transitory.
For these reasons, the FOMC decided to keep the federal funds rate at its current low level (0%-0.25%). The FOMC expressed some concern about the strength of the dollar and its affects on the exports markets. The Fed asserted that it is unlikely to raise the federal funds rate at its April meeting.
This lesson dives deeper into the language the Fed uses to communicate its policies and intentions, comparing the last two reports. The Fed also releases its dot plots as a way to signal what individual members of the policy committee are thinking with respect to the appropriate level of rate increase and its timing.
In December, the Fed's prediction of the range of unemployment rate that would be consistent with stable inflation was 5.2 to 5.5 percent. In this latest release, they have revised downward that range to 5.0 to 5.2 percent. Ask students why they think they revised their estimate? (the current level of unemployment is 5.5 percent and inflation is not at their desired 2% level). Ask what evidence from the labor market they think would indicate to the Fed that the unemployment rate has reached a level that is consistent with a stable rate of inflation? (when wage rates start increasing significantly, that will indicate that most of the slack in the labor market is gone).
Presenter: Doug Young